[Matney's Prodigey]

WOW... I was almost positive the question was is he the best in the NFL RIGHT NOW. Meaning at this point in time as in not meaning over an entire career. If you were going by stats/QB rating alone...you would have to say yes. We will see for sure after their bye week in the head to head game against Indy. Maybe you should have asked this question after that game. Of course this isn't THE BIG GAME so the chances of Manning choking aren't very good. (Have to have a playoff game on the line for him to choke. ) As for Brady...he had a Defense that kept giving him the ball in crucial moments. Sure he won 2 SB's but put any decent QB into the line-up they had and the outcome would most likely have been the same. However, as you can see from the Pats record this season, they sure are missing those key defensive players who have been sidelined with injuries. (Brady=Overrated)

GO BENGALS!!

Check the math my friend. 3 Super Bowls, not 2. How can you say a person who has yet to play in a meaningful game is the best QB in the league RIGHT NOW? He hasn't cracked under pressure because when you are out of the playoff hunt there is no pressure. Untill he at least makes the playoffs he shouldn't be considered the best. Maybe the best fantasy QB, but we all know how much that is worth. (Palmer = Not proven = Overrated)