[#55PirateFan]

Title losses are not counted against themselves. A team with 10 titles loses and no wins would have 5 points from State Title games not -5 points.

Take the real example:
(No team on the list has 0 appearances so I will pull out one to compare)
The full state title value is calculated as below

(State Title Score + State Title Era Modifier) which is the below formula
(Appearance + W Weight + L Weight) + (post Weight + pre-weight)

Rockastle (0-2) has 1pt total for State Title Score
(2 + 0 + -1) = (2 + -1) = 1

Russell (1-1) has 2 points for State Title Score
(2 + .5 + -.5) = (2.5 + -.5) = 2

Bell Co.(2-0) has 3 points for State Title Score
(2 + 1 + 0) = 3

Pike Central
(0 + 0 + 0) = 0

Then the era modifier is added to that to get the overall total points for state titles.

As you can see Rock is not negative points for losing a state title, and therefore are not worse or below Pike Central who has no appearances. Is it the best formula for valuing state titles? Probably not, but I don't think I would say it's nonsense. Alos if you have a better calculation I would love to see it.

Great job buddy! Keep doing what your doing. You can't satisfy everyone. There's always a few that chimes in and makes some comment about something that was never said. If they would just read the comment and comprehend it, they might just understand what your talking about.