[jayblackcat2006]

It's hilarious that you all put Ben in the top 5. I personally don't like him and i hate the steelers even more. But without bias, it's just his 2nd season so you can't rank him with guys that have been out there 6+ years. He'd be between #12 and #15 on a list of "best" current QBs. Here's how it goes now.....

1. Peyton Manning
2. Donovan McNabb
3. Carson Palmer
4. Tom Brady
5. Brett Favre

That may be the most accurate list once you switch Brady and Palmer. While Palmer may be the better talent and have the most potential, Tom Brady is proven. No doubt Donovan McNabb is #2, while Vick may get more rushing yards, McNabb is just as good of a double-threat if not better, because of his extraordinary combination of lethal accuracy and throwing strenght with great wheels.