[Stardust]

Stardust, I will give you the fact that his winning record is a little inflated, in relation to how good of a QB he is, but his record is SOOOO good. With a record that good, you have to be a winner. Remember the Titans record BEFORE he took over last season? The only change was at QB and he lead them to, (I think) 8 straight wins.

As overhyped as he is, he takes care of the most important stat: wins.

Umm, does anyone give Boise St and BYU credit for having undefeated seasons in college football? Has anyone been truly impressed with San Diego State and the undefeated run they started this season off with?

No. The argument that they have such great records is that they play inferior competition and if they played in the SEC, Big East, ACC, etc..., these teams would be middle of the pack.

Young's record is the same as these teams. He has a great career record as a starter, but he is 13-14 against teams with a winning record. A sub .500 record does not make you an outstanding QB, it puts you in the middle of the pack and no better than that.