[NEWARKCATHOLICFAN]

Would you sign with a school you grew up hating that is a legit top 10 team every year or sign with a lesser school. Just for kicks let’s say you have the same chance to see the field at both schools.

[EKUAlum05]

Based solely and specifically on the criteria you laid out it would be hard for anyone not to go with the Top 10 school:

But important factors left out;
- Offensive/Defensive System
- Track record of putting players in the NFL
- Will they recruit over you?
- Coach Stability
- Distance
- Academics
- Competition/Strength of Schedule
- Facilities
- Sense of ownership, some players want to be "The Guy" to turn a program around
- Television Contract?

[NEWARKCATHOLICFAN]

Just for this exercise we will say all things are equal at both schools.

I was trying not to make this a complicatded thing but I should have know it wasn't going to be that easy. (lol)