[tradition]

This isn't about the best team, it is about the best player. Based on your logic Mr. Football should go to the starting running back at Trinity because Trinity would beat Highlands, Breathitt, and Simon Kenton.

If Fugate or Simpson went to Highlands then Collinsworth would still be at WR instead of RB.

I agree with you, I felt the thread was heading in the direction of who would beat whom, which, like you, I also felt was a twisted way of deciding who was the better player.