Thread Rating:
03-18-2009, 03:24 PM
ComfortEagle Wrote:I never said that she doesn't deserve SOMETHING. Plain, and simple, it's impossible to put a monetary value on oneself. If her family wanted to, they could sue for 100 billion, but what's the likelihood that they would get that much money?Do you have direct evidence that Xanax was responsible for the incident? All that is is one person's theory on trying to understand why this could have happened. There has never been any proof offerered to determine that as any direct evidence.
I think there's a bit of contradiction in your statement though. You say that myself along with others on this board are in denial that animals can go off the deep end without warning. If you've followed this incident, there have been several times when this chimp has caused problems. The fact that the owner was giving it Xanax also shows that the owner knew this chimp could have more problems. She knew the chimp had problems and could potentially have more. Upon knowing that, it's really not going off the deep end without warning. The warning were in all of the previous incidents and obviously the mood that the chimp was in earlier in the day for the owner to give it Xanax.
I stick by my opinion that improper training causes more problems in dog attacks, than genetics. It is a fact that pit bulls are not the most likely breed to bite or attack, however, if they do bite, they are more likely to cause a worse bite than say a miniature poodle.
Now, was the chimp owner in the wrong for trying to keep a wild animal locked in her house for it's whole life? Yes. Was the chimp owner in the wrong for giving it precription drugs without a doctors consent? Yes. Should she have known that, given this chimp's history, that it could potentially get out of control? Yes.
Dogs and chimps, or any wild animals, are different topics, so let's try not to let this stray that direction, but since it was brought up, I will reiterate what I believe.
Any dog with proper training and good owner handling can be a good dog. I do not believe any dogs are more pre-disposed to attack or bite, but they can be trained to be that way. I do not believe pit bulls naturally harbor any more aggression than any other dog, however, if they do bite, can obviously cause more harm than most other dogs. It is this knowledge and responsibility that needs to be held by potential owners of pit bulls, and I think there are a lot of pit bull owners who do not know/care what bad training can lead to, but rather, all they care is about is the "coolness" of owning a pit bull. I do not blame the owners of pit bulls for how bad their dog's bite is, I blame them for allowing the dog to get into that situation and/or not properly training them against it.
To wrap all of this back up, the chimp owner knew this chimp had problems and could potentially have more, hence the Xanax. And I agree that the victim should be awarded a large sum of money, but what is reasonable and what is not? And is it even possible to place a set value on that?
All the more reason to be responsible enough to realize that a potentially deadly animal has no place being placed in a subjective manner to a social setting.....lol....Kinda like being smart enough to realize that it' probably a better idea to own a garter snake than a rattlesnake, huh? Your pet garter snake bite's your friend, he'll laugh about it, your pet rattlesnake bite's him , he can die. It's no different. You can say I'm being exteme and silly, but honestly it's not.
Remember the tiger that mauled Roy of Sigfried and Roy. It was raised from birth by those guys. One day, all of a sudden it just snapped.
I'll close in saying this. I despise lawyers. They have destroyed the ability of America to do business through trival and frivilous lawsuits that have bogged the American justice system down. Their ambulance chasing ways have left it almost impossible for most small American businesses to be able to exist, BUT in a case where it is nothing but just plain pure negligence and total indifference to human safety on the part of an animal owner then they have IMO everything coming to them by being subjected to extreme financial responsiblies to the afflicted, as well as paying the price of possible incarceration. I have no sympathy to anyone who doesn't care about my safety, my family's safety, or their communities safety all for the sake of owning some animal.
Messages In This Thread
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Kimball - 03-17-2009, 10:04 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by jetpilot - 03-17-2009, 10:18 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by ComfortEagle - 03-17-2009, 10:19 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Spud6 - 03-17-2009, 10:32 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Kimball - 03-17-2009, 10:41 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Kimball - 03-17-2009, 10:42 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by ComfortEagle - 03-17-2009, 11:00 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Pond creek nation - 03-17-2009, 11:26 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Kimball - 03-18-2009, 12:40 AM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by ComfortEagle - 03-18-2009, 12:17 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by jetpilot - 03-18-2009, 01:24 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Kimball - 03-18-2009, 02:18 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Kimball - 03-18-2009, 03:24 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by jetpilot - 03-18-2009, 11:30 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Kimball - 03-18-2009, 11:44 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by cougarpride08 - 03-19-2009, 01:51 PM
Chimp Attack Victim Sues For 50 Million Dollars - by Mr.Mister - 03-20-2009, 04:13 AM
Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)