[Deathstar 80]

I don't think they should.

If you're talking about the students who were forced to home school because of a serious illness, etc., then they physically couldn't play in the first place.

If you're talking about an adult choosing to send their child to home school, then they should still be refused for eligibility for the reason that some of those parents might use the advantage of making their children eligible for sports. It's unfair for other students who are in home school and put education above athletics as they should, but it must be done for the best of the home-schooled students as a whole.