[More Cowbell]

1. Todd May
2. everyone else

I agree, this is the only real way to answer this question...

As for those who are putting VanHoose first, over May, I would just say sorry, but no. VanHoose was a great player, and I respect his accomplishments, but Todd May was in another league. Both in high school and during his playing days at Pikeville College. It's a shame we'll never know what he would have done had he stayed at UK, but he still has to get the nod for this question, hands down.