[Jshort5]

Well, me being a Pirates fan, I have to say Jason Bay, at .289 with 17 hr, 45 rbi, scored 62 runs and has 6 stolen bases. Xavier Nady has had a monster year too, batting .323 with 12 hr, 55 rbi, scored 42 runs....I think they both have had good enough seasons to make it, but thats the problem I have with the whole thing. The fans vote should be LIMITED to whoever makes it. Make the fans vote 1/3 of it, then players that deserve to go, can, instead of the same ol players every year. And Big Papi batting .252 with 13 homers and 43 rbi??? And HE led the voting. THATS the problem with the all star game, regardless whether or not he plays. A guy that dont field, with numbers like that shouldnt lead the voting..

Mark my words, Tommy Gorzelanny will be an all-star more than once in his career, not this year but maybe next year or the next.