[More Cowbell]

My vote would go to McFadden only because he will play a tougher schedule than the rest. Like some others on here have said, if he puts up numbers like last year or goes above them, then he should win it. Slaton plays against weak competition, as well as Booty and Brohm and Brennan. So its easy for those guys to put up big numbers. Unfortunately my vote doesnt count and the heisman will most likely go to Booty because USC somehow gets everything to go their way, why not the Heisman again.

That is the very reason why I think it will be Slaton. Have you see West Virginia's schedule this year? What a joke, UK would win 9-10 games against that sorry bunch. He will put up some ridiculous numbers, the team will finish with 11-12 wins, and the Heisman voters will be impressed enough to give it to him. However, I think if it was given to the best player, McFadden should get it.