[More Cowbell]

The All-American team doesn't focus as much on team success, so if he puts up the numbers he defintely has a shot at one of the teams...

If that's the case, then to me the All-America team has more credibility than the Heisman. These are supposed to be awards in recognition of great players, not great teams. One man can't win the games by himself, the other guys on the field have to perform too. You shouldn't penalize a great player for being on a mediocre team.