[Scotty doesn't know]

I myself think that the team should trade whichever of the two will fetch the best return. Dunn is younger and has more upside (potentially), but his contract is such that if he is traded he becomes a free agent after this year, making him only a stretch-run rental. Griffey, on the other hand, is the more complete player, and his contract is not outrageous considering how well he is playing this year, but you never know when he could have another season-ending injury (not his fault, but the guy is fragile).

On a side note, I think a guy like Weathers would be very valuable to a team in a playoff chase, and should bring back some good talent in return.

I guess this poll is more about who I think will be traded if anyone. So I will change my answer from earlier. I would like to see Dunn go (if it came to that), but I heard yesterday that Junior is unhappy (I am not for sure about the source). He did the Reds a favor by coming with a reasonable contract so I say let him be happy and trade him.