[Iggyfan]

As a parent, if I had a student in elementary school I would have them repeat the grade regardless of their academic performance because of what was lost in terms of social development.
Beyond that, every child is different and each situation needs to be looked at individually but I do believe that nothing is lost if the child repeats a grade.

As far as high school students who are repeating a grade only to gain an advantage athletically, I think the decision is misguided and defeats the spirit of the rule. I may be wrong, but would not be surprised to see KHSAA clarify the rule and state that athletic eligibility is limited to 8 consecutive semesters.