[More Cowbell]

Seems like everyone agrees on who the top 5 teams are. Here's the updated tally of how each of the top 5 has fared against each other:

Johnson Co. = 3-4 (0-2 vs Martin, 1-1 Paints, 1-1 Valley, 1-0 Pike)
Martin = 5-2 (2-0 vs Johnson, 1-1 Paints, 1-0 Valley, 1-1 Pike)
Paintsville = 4-2 (1-1 vs Johnson, 1-1 Martin, 1-0 Valley, 1-0 Pike)
Valley = 4-3 (1-1 vs Johnson, 0-1 Martin, 0-1 Paints, 3-0 Pike)
Pikeville = 1-6 (0-1 vs Johnson, 1-1 Martin, 0-1 Paints, 0-3 Valley)

Based on this, you would have to give the top spot to Martin Co, with Paintsville close behind at #2. I would put Valley at #3, with Johnson right behind them. Then Pikeville slots in at #5.

I could still see any of these teams beating any of the others at regionals, though. Despite Pikeville having only a 1-6 record against the others, they own a win over the #1 team in Martin, and both their recent losses to Martin and Paintsville were each by only 1 point.

After the top 5, I could put the next several teams being ranked in any order. They could easily win a game at the Expo, but I don't see them being able to win 3 straight to take the crown.