[MayfieldCardinal]

Granny said it was a total of 4 votes that seperated CAL and DeSales. Likely some did not give CAL enough of a deep study or were too dismissive of their win over DeSales. Like I said in an earlier post, it will balance out, like many rankings do. But to say ONE ranking you don't agree with hurts the credibility of the entire rankings system shows you probably won't agree with nor see that distinction either.

I was paid off!!!
nicker:


Seriously, you would have to ask the folks who volunteered to do the rankings why they chose it that way. CAL was close to DeSales, I went back to check and it was a 4 point (NOT votes) difference.

So MY explanation would be that this was the way the panel ranked those teams over all.

And no, it doesn't hurt the credibility of the entire rankings in every class, IMO.

Friday night Cal 16 DeSales 0 In a head to head district game and CAL's strength of schedule is superior and both are now 5-2. So the polls roll out and DeSales is ranked higher, no matter 4 points or 400 they are higher and I am looking for some logic as to why.
The bolded in each quote I do not agree with. There is no logic I can see that would find DeSales ranked ahead of CAL.
Surely someone who voted can so some splainin :insane: