[LWC]

I think championships should have at least 25% weight or more for the QB but it should not matter for any other position.

The QB is directly responsible for calling plays, audibles, and getting the ball distributed to different players whether through a pass or handoff.

No, the QB does not play defense but also that is neither here nor there. No matter how good a defense is, a game cannot be won unless you score more points than the other team. Unless your team's defense is legendary and wins games through INT and fumble returns for touchdowns, the offense or (rarely) special teams must score.

One must for any QB to ever be the greatest is they must have won at least one NFL championship. You play to win the game, not to collect stats.

Thus, for me the criterion for greatest QB ever should be determined in this order:
1. Passing TD's to INT's ratio
2. Passing TD's
3. Super Bowl rings
4. Conference championships
5. Low number of turnovers relative to similar players (i.e. Player A and B are similar except player A had 400 fumbles and player B had 150.)
5. Regular season wins
6. Passing yards
7. Extra stats (rushing yards, receiving yards, etch..)

The next post will have my list.