[UPIKEFAN]

An unquestioned transfer just opens the door for open recruiting by everyone.

So, what would you call that door now? Ajar? I'm not saying do away with the bylaw, you enforce it more rigorously if a transfer moves for a 2nd time.

Most, if not all, schools recruit already. I can't see how in the world a change like this would make things any worse.

As for no transfers, no chance that would ever happen because, regardless what some might believe, there are legitimate reasons for a move and you would be punishing kids for spite, and nothing else.