[Ultimaterebelfan]

I don't have a strong case, but I can make an argument. Highlands D played straight up. Trinity was stunting, blitzing, etc. Highlands also played a ton of guys on defense that wouldn't get in a regular game against Trinity. Do I think Highlands would beat them. No. But, it wouldn't be a blowout. Highlands would beat Cincy X again too.

So Highlands never blitzed a LB or CB in that scrimmage? I'm pretty sure I saw the LBs blitz several times, especially in the red zone.
I don't know who you played on D but I can't imagine playing kids against Trinity that wouldn't get in a normal game, unless you're talking about as the game was winding down. Why wouldn't you play your regulars in a scrimmage? That's what it's for.
I wouldn't necessarily call 38-14 a blowout, but I didn't think there was any doubt who was the better team once it was over. I think a real game would have been more lopsided than that. I have my reasons for saying that and I'm sure you will disagree and have your reasons.
I don't think you would beat Cincy X this year. I'm not sure you could score on their D (Trinity did only score 17) and I don't think there's any way you could hold them to 1 score as Trinity did. I'm sure you will disagree with this as well.