[PHSForever]

Huff and Roark are the best I have seen at this point in the season.

I love Randy, but he is not a pure QB. He is one of the better football players in the area. A football player that is needed at QB for the Panthers.

Then you have Boggs who piles up huge numbers, still looking for that signature win.

Crisp is solid.

PT, I agree. There are other QB's who are much better QB's than Randy. One of my main reasons for even listing him in consideration is that I feel we've overlooked something VERY important when having this discussion: leadership. You point out the excellent point that he is a very good football player who is needed at QB. And therein lies my point, that the mark of a true, very good QB is one who leads his team while also demonstrating if not mastership of QB skills, at least very strong skills. Randy has a very decent arm, outstanding scrambling abilities, outstanding safety skills, and very nice hands (as shown by his play at WR against Tellico). He will never be a Boggs, Huff, or Roark, but I'd build a team around him any day, based on his leadership and character. Like Boggs, however, he is searching for that true signature win, IMO.