[ekff]

The reason I think Manning is overrated is the big games. Right or wrong, a starting QB's legacy is big games. Manning has come up short in big games his entire career. At Tennessee, he goes 0-4 against Florida and won with only one SEC title. Manning has been surrounded by offensive talent his entire career, Marshall Faulk (HOF), Edgerin (SP?) James in his prime (Borderline HOF), Marvin Harrison (Future HOF), Reggie Wayne (Number 1 reciever on most teams), Jeff Saturday (One of the best centers in the game possible HOF), good O-Line. All that talent surrounding him and he has a 9-10 career playoff record with 7 one and dones. Manning is a great regular season QB. I would take him over anybody as my QB in a game in September, just not in the playoffs. IMO, he is not one of the two best ever.

YOUR CRAZY....

Manning has NEVER been surrounded by talent...... Never had a go-get-in WR.... Manning has made his WR's what they are.... Just look at Yards After Catch....

Mannings never had a Andre Johnson, Randy Moss, Terrell Owens, WR's that go up and get the ball, Manning has to put the ball in the right place ever time for anyone of his team to catch it, and yes Wayne too....

As for the BIG GAME TALK!!!! Manning is only on one side of the ball..... Colts D has never played good in big games..... Manning gets his....

If Garon, Collie, White, and Jacob Tamme is talent then the NFL sucks....

Oh Yeah, Manning don't throw screens and let players run 50 yards... (Brady)......