[Stardust]

Stardust the only reason I had hope is because of all the other rulings the NCAA kept making. The Selby one in particular. According the the NCAA it wasn't how much Kanter took but they fact he took money from a professional organization. I guess that professional agent Selby took money from must have been the NCAA's mulligan. How is are those two different? If it wasnt the amount of money but just the act of accepting benefits then Selby should be forced to sit out as well.

The inconsistancies are just too much to understand or accept.

I guess I didn't address your comments about Selby, or guys like Newton. I do not feel they should be eligible, i did not agree with the NCAA on this. But UK was not pointed out because they are UK. There were other cases of players being ruled permanently ineligible this year as well. But let's be clear, it was not the NCAA who upheld the initial ruling, it was a committee of colleges, with no one from the NCAA on that committee. The Eligibility committee is who ruled in favor of the NCAA's original decision. The Eligibility committee has our own Barnhart on that committee. So, Barnhart himself would have been involved in other cases this year that ruled other athletes permanently ineligible himself.