[outdoorsman43]

Look, you know me, I truly do love the Cats, and I may be the most brutally honest fan of them. But in this case, I see it tough to overlook the fact that he has an unfair advantage over any other college athlete. I used my scenario below about a 16 year-old playing pro ball in Mexico, then going to my rival HS to compete against a team that I am coaching. I would fight against that athlete.

I've heard the argument many times that this is the way they do it overseas. So? That does not make it different. The NCAA does not allow 16 year-old CHL players come to US colleges and play college hockey. Kanter didn't go and play against other 16 year-olds, he played against men! He played against men who have played in the NBA already. No, IMO, he is not eligible to play collegiate sports.

BUT! And this is my contention, the NCAA is taking a long time on this. I have an understanding of legal proceedings, and the longer something goes, the better it is for the defendant. In this case, the longer this goes, the better it is that the NCAA finds a way to allow these situations to be reviewed differently. I felt a week ago that the NCAA is going to likely declare that he has to sit a year, and then be eligible once he pays back his $33K. Does it change my opinion of should he be eligible, No! I'd still fight against the 16 year-old baseball player as well!

I understand the unfair advantage that Kanter had playing against tougher competition. But really, how much of an advantage does that give you? The kid only did what he thought he was supposed to do. That's really the argument that the Kanter's have is that they thought they were doing things the right way. Although they broke the rules, pretty big rules at that, I still think the NCAA should take that into account (should have already) and base the his eligibility on that.

The NCAA should and will make the new rules, exceptions, etc. after this ruling but they certainly shouldn't base Kanter's ruling on these new rules like the media has been told they are going to do. It could be good for Enes or it could be bad for Enes. I don't know.