[Tomcat68]

Darrell also has to overcome his butter fingers that he showed in nearly every varsity game this season when he saw the field. A QB that can't play without fumbling somewhere between the snap and handoff more than once in a blue moon will never see extensive playing time.

When he throws, Mahan has a great arm. I think in all, his arm is better than Drew's.

Drew brings the diversity as being one of the fastest people on the field and a large threat of a running quarterback.

You also have to think that making Drew the QB hampers the passing game by taking him away as the best receiver on next year's team. That is another advantage for Mahan to get the nod over Drew.

In all honesty, I'd like to see McDavid get 15-20 touches a ball game, whether it be throwing, running, or catching the ball. He is most likely the most dominant player on the team along with Fields Davis. If he doesn't get many touches, I don't see this as being as successful season for Ashland as it could be.