[MayfieldCardinal]

Two great qb's, Combs was named 1A player of the year while Guhy was selected 2nd team CJ All State. Who would you choose to qb your team if you had a choice between these 2 great qb's?

[MayfieldCardinal]

I am biased but I prefer Guhy but Combs numbers were stagering as were Guhy's. The title game tilted my opinion to Guhy and his stellar preformance likely won over several votes by the coaches for All State given the large number of coaches in attendance.

[toussaints]

this is a tough call. seemed like guhy had more to work with, but id still take guhy only based on the title game