[LWC]

Who is it? Please provide some stats/argument

[MVP2]

Scott Rolen.


8 time gold glove winner.

Could be the best defensive 3rd basemen in the game. He can still hit, maybe not have the power like his younger days but he can still hit for contact and drive in runs. I think he is very underated.


Over 300 HRs
Over 1200 RBIs
Over 100 stolen bases
Over 1900 hits.

[Jimmy Dugan]

Jacoby Ellsbury- Leads the league in stolen bases, batting average is 302, and made the all star team. In my opinion one of the best defensive players in baseball.

[MVP2]

I think Andrew Mccutchen is very underated as well. Probably not the most underated but IMO he is very underated, dont get much credit for how good his game is.

[LWC]

Is McCutchen a Pirate?

[MVP2]

^

Yes.