[ComfortEagle]

The following is a great article by Mike DeCourcy of Sporting News:
http://www.sportingnews.com/nba/article/...s-have-pay

It is not uncommon for history to be altered after it is written. Pluto once was considered a planet but now is not. Harry Truman left office with an approval rating in the low 20s but eventually became the model of the modern Democrat. Jim Rice was not deemed worthy of baseball's Hall of Fame for 14 years, and then he was.
Villanova in 1971, UCLA in 1980 and Ohio State in 1999 all competed in the NCAA Final Four, but they no longer are considered Final Four teams.

So the NCAA infractions committee's decision to vacate Memphis' accomplishments from the 2007-08 basketball season is not without precedent. And yet it appears to be unprecedented.

Because out of all the previous Final Four teams that have disappeared into history's dumpster, none arrived there with an arm of the NCAA serving as an unwitting participant in the transgression.

Before Derrick Rose could play basketball at the University of Memphis, the NCAA eligibility clearinghouse examined his academic records, including his standardized test score, and determined they met the minimum standards for eligibility to compete as a freshman.

Memphis accepted this verification and used Rose as the team's point guard in 40 games, 38 of which the Tigers won, including five in the NCAA Tournament.
A little more than a month after Rose missed a free throw that might have clinched the NCAA championship for the Tigers, the Educational Testing Service cancelled Rose's qualifying SAT score, technically rendering him ineligible to have played in that game.

Thursday, we were told two things about this transaction by NCAA infractions committee chair Paul Dee.
• "When you have a situation where information is not known at the time, and information appears to be valid on its face, then I assess no blame. Because the score was cancelled after the fact, it's hard to say that anyone could have foreseen that would happen."
This was his response when asked about the apparent inefficacy of the clearinghouse that approved Rose's eligibility.
• "The matter of initial eligibility is one of the NCAA rules where there is strict liability. Not infrequently, we find that information comes to light after a student/athlete has participated. For example, if a student/athlete becomes a professional ...
"If the student/athlete is academically ineligible, the penalty is related back to the time."

This was Dee's response when asked how Memphis could be punished for unknowingly utilizing an ineligible player.

This outrageous double standard leaves Memphis with an historic season that has been erased from history. The NCAA has ordered the school to remove any banners or signs that acknowledge the 2008 Final Four trip and to remove any recognition of the 38 victories from its media guide and other publications. It even declared coach John Calipari will have the 38 wins removed from his career record.
The university, to its credit, defended itself against the allegations at a June hearing and tried to fend off the vacating of its records. An appeal is planned. There is a financial component to the penalty for Memphis—having to return the money it earned for participating in the tournament—but Calipari has moved on to Kentucky and Rose now plays for the Chicago Bulls. Many schools in Memphis' situation would have accepted this punishment so long as there were no serious sanctions affecting future teams.

Many reporters on Thursday's conference call were consumed with the revelation that Rose's eventually-to-be-nullified SAT score was achieved in Detroit, which they seemed to accept as evidence that some chicanery had occurred.
However, a source close to the Memphis program told Sporting News that when Rose was first going through the initial eligibility process, he told the school and the NCAA he had taken the test in Detroit because the Bulls were playing the Pistons in a playoff game, and members of his family had planned to attend. The source said Rose has insisted to former teammates and members of the Bulls organization that he took his own test, although he has made no public statement on the matter.
It's interesting, though, that the infractions committee probed no deeper into the question of whether Rose had, in fact, taken that test. The most essential question of this entire controversy was decided when the Educational Testing Service cancelled Rose's test score in May 2008.

And why did that happen? Because the ETS sent letters to Rose's home in Chicago a couple months earlier—when Rose was attending school in Memphis and on the road playing the NCAA Tournament—and he did not respond to them.
The cancellation of the test was "based on failure to cooperate," Dee acknowledged. So an action this profound, this lasting, was undertaken at least partly because Rose didn't get his mail.

Isn't anyone else bothered by this?
Shouldn't history be rewritten by someone smart enough to recognize that a student at the University of Memphis might be spending most of his time in Memphis?

[cougarpride08]

NCAA messes up on a lot of things.

[Strikeout King]

i think this is NCAA's fault because they went ahead and let him play

[Nefarious83]

The NCAA should do a better job, they let too many things go.

[bigben]

The NCAA should do a better job, they let too many things go.

:worthy: they do let too many things go

[Scotty doesn't know]

I dont understand why the NCAA cant take a little blame and realize that the team only played him because he was cleared by the NCAA clearing house.

[belfry forever]

The NCAA won't take blame because the NCAA is "perfect" ...(at least they think they are! lol!)

[lil dog]

I think that Rose cheated... not Memphis.....and Rose should have to pay the NCAA the money that Memphis got for playing in the Tournament, these athletes should be held responsible for their own actions..... not the school that didnt know he cheated !!!!!