[ekff]

http://top100.nfl.com/

Voted on by the players!!!!

I made my own list but that's for another thread....

What's everyone's Underrated and Overrated players on this list?

And Who are some players that should be on the list that aren't on it?

IMO:

Under-Rated:
Patrick Willis - LB (23)
Frank Gore - RB (94)
Brian Urlacher - LB (49)
Lance Briggs - LB (92)
Jared Allen - DE (80)
Ndamukong Suh - DT (51)
Joe Thomas - LT (43)
Adrian Wilson - CB (89)
Mario Williams - DE (71)


Over-Rated:
Ray Lewis - LB (4)
Jamaal Charles - RB (33)
Santonio Holmes - WR (76)
Vonta Leach - FB (65)
Josh Freeman - QB (86)
Devin Hester - WR (32)
Shaun Phillips - DE (97)


Players Left Off:
Eli Manning - QB
Jay Cutler - QB
Peyton Hillis - RB
Matt Forte - RB
LeSean McCoy - RB
Reshard Mendenhall - RB
Anquan Boldin - WR
Sidney Rice - WR
Hakeem Nicks - WR
Bob Sanders - S

^All these players are on my list

[Stardust]

I was surprised when I heard that the players called Ray over-rated. Look for him to kill someone this year (well, kill someone on the field this time)

[zaga_fan]

I was surprised when I heard that the players called Ray over-rated. Look for him to kill someone this year (well, kill someone on the field this time)

That's the last man in the league I want to see after I cut in between the tackles lol

[ekff]

I was surprised when I heard that the players called Ray over-rated. Look for him to kill someone this year (well, kill someone on the field this time)

I've always been a Ray Lewis fan... And Ray has been a great player and is still a good player but I don't think he's the 4th best player in the league. I believe he has fell off a little.. But he is in the TOP 100!!!!

[LWC]

I've always been a Ray Lewis fan... And Ray has been a great player and is still a good player but I don't think he's the 4th best player in the league. I believe he has fell off a little.. But he is in the TOP 100!!!!

:Thumbs:

[Aslan]

I've always been a Ray Lewis fan... And Ray has been a great player and is still a good player but I don't think he's the 4th best player in the league. I believe he has fell off a little.. But he is in the TOP 100!!!!

Agreed.

[ekff]

One thing I want to see how people feel is "Josh Freeman!" What does everyone think about Freeman making the list over Eli and Cutler? Personally I didn't like it...

I know Eli had some bad INT's last year but he still had 31 TD's and 4,000 yds.....

Cutler has the worst O-line in the league but still had an OK season..

[LWC]

^I am really high on Josh Freeman and really low on Eli. Jay Cutler should have made the list. Eli has been highly overrated for years, however he is a Super Bowl Champion. So, with the NFL being a QB league, I would put them all in. Jay and Eli being in the 90's and Freeman is fine where he is.

[Aslan]

^I am really high on Josh Freeman and really low on Eli. Jay Cutler should have made the list. Eli has been highly overrated for years, however he is a Super Bowl Champion. So, with the NFL being a QB league, I would put them all in. Jay and Eli being in the 90's and Freeman is fine where he is.

I seriously couldn't agree more, especially the bolded.

[ekff]

^ I don't think Eli is over-rated and never has been.... How can someone be over-rated when he doesn't make the players top 100 player list, and never gets talked about.....

I thought you all would like Eli since you like players that make game winning drives at the end.... (Super Bowl).... Maybe its just that last name that hurts him....

[LWC]

^ekff, don't lump me into the 4th quarter drive-lovers, lol. I think they are crucial but if someone has a bad 3-quarters the complete game should be viewed badly. The first so-many minutes are just as important as the last 3.

The players do not over-rate Eli, the media does.

When I was thinking about my list, in another thread, I looked at who would be great if they were taken off their current team and placed on any other. I do not think Eli could make a team better, I think his team makes him better. If he got dropped in Carolina, he would do not much better than the QB's they already have.

[zaga_fan]

I think Eli is underrated and Peyton is overrated

[Stardust]

^ No way is Peyton overrated. Peyton CREATED a system. Think about it if he could have played IN a system. Put him into the Patriots system and Peyton does better than Brady!

[Aslan]

^ekff, don't lump me into the 4th quarter drive-lovers, lol. I think they are crucial but if someone has a bad 3-quarters the complete game should be viewed badly. The first so-many minutes are just as important as the last 3.

The players do not over-rate Eli, the media does.

When I was thinking about my list, in another thread, I looked at who would be great if they were taken off their current team and placed on any other. I do not think Eli could make a team better, I think his team makes him better. If he got dropped in Carolina, he would do not much better than the QB's they already have.

Every time I'm about to come with a response, you already got it! :Thumbs:

^ No way is Peyton overrated. Peyton CREATED a system. Think about it if he could have played IN a system. Put him into the Patriots system and Peyton does better than Brady!

False.

[ekff]

I think Eli is underrated and Peyton is overrated

I respected you!!!!

Dumbest thing I've ever seen you say....

Me and you are going to have a little talk at the courts LOL

[LClion4life]

^ No way is Peyton overrated. Peyton CREATED a system. Think about it if he could have played IN a system. Put him into the Patriots system and Peyton does better than Brady!

:Thumbs: irateSho :worthy: :Clap: :Thumbs:

[WALL2WALL]

This top 100 is bogus. Troy Polamalu should be ranked 4th. Ed Reed would be in that position 3 or 4 years ago, but not now. Big Ben should be ranked higher than that to, he is better than Phillip Rivers.

[LClion4life]

I'd take Rivers over Ben.

[Spud6]

I'd take Rivers over Ben.

Rings show otherwise.

[LClion4life]

Yeah, and Ben has played with the best and most consistent defense since he's been in the league. Rivers is a much better passer, leader, and knows how to run an offense more smoothly.