[Wildcat18]

So, my question is if a coach has never won a state champions he can't be a great coach and if a coach has won a state championship he is a great coach?
Does this also mean if a coach wins 1 year he's a great coach but if he only wins 5 games the next he is no longer a great coach?
Do you think Tubby won the 98 championship because he was a great coach or because he had great talent?

Tubby is a good comparison. I think he's a good coach, just not great. In 2003, he had the best team in the tournament and lost. Look at Coach Cal. In 2010, he had THE most athletic team in the NCAA and underachieved against a terrible West Virginia team. The next year in 2011, he took a mediocre team and went to the final four. You can look at it both ways.