Vote and discuss!
Posted 15 Jan 2005 04:23 pm:
IMO Without P.Manning.. The colts would be lucky to even make the playoffs!
I would say Manning because he has had a great season.. but i don't think the Steelers would be where they're at either if it wasn't for Roethlisberger, he proved this season that he was going to be a great QB.
Manning!!!!! thats a given.
Seems we all agree Peyton is the shit!
Michael Vick
Last season the Falcons were 5-11 with Vick injured.
This season with Vick back they are 11-5 and in the playoffs.
Manning
But That's over now
The best QB right now is McNabb !
I said Manning and after this week I guess we know why.
I like Vick to but as far as success goes Manning wins easy.
Right now without T.O., you have to pick Donovan McNabb. The Colts would still have the Big 3 and Edge w/o Peyton. The Eagles wouldn't have any offense period with the exception of Brian Westbrook
"Captain Morgan" Wrote:Michael Vick
Last season the Falcons were 5-11 with Vick injured.
This season with Vick back they are 11-5 and in the playoffs.
Agree 100%
To not have Michael Vick listed is a joke, Manning is nowhere close to Vick importance wise, the Colts would make the playoffs without Manning, but you saw what happened to the Vick-less falcons last year, and this year he immediately led them back to the NFC championship game.